Baseline tests dropped as progress measure

Apr 7, 2016 by

Baseline tests for reception pupils in England are not reliable enough to measure progress this year, says a study for the Department for Education.

The education department, which is introducing the tests, says it would be “unfair” to use them as a measure.

There are three different testing systems that schools can use – but the study says the results are not “sufficiently comparable”.

A head teachers’ union said: “It is hard to avoid saying ‘we told you so’.”

Tests for pupils at the beginning of school, known as “baseline tests”, were intended as a starting point against which to measure progress through primary school.


But they have faced opposition from teachers’ union leaders who criticised them as introducing an unnecessary set of tests for young children.

The Department for Education has now backed away from using the tests for measuring progress this year – after publishing a study that it had commissioned looking at the comparability of the three testing systems.

“That study has shown that the assessments are not sufficiently comparable to provide a fair starting point from which to measure pupil progress,” says a statement from the Department for Education.

“In light of that, we will not be using this year’s results as the baseline for progress measures. This would be inappropriate and unfair to schools.”

The study from the Standards and Testing Agency concluded that the tests in literacy and numeracy, with three separate systems in use, were not sufficiently comparable. As such the results could not be reliably used in the “accountability system”.

The National Association of Head Teachers said the government had “outsmarted itself by choosing multiple providers of these assessments – none of which compare to each other”.

“They cannot provide a measure of progress that can be compared between schools.

“This outcome is symptomatic of the general chaos on assessment in the primary phase, with poor planning and a lack of consultation with the people who know what will actually work.”

Delegates at the National Union of Teachers had attacked baseline tests at their annual conference at Easter. The union said that its campaign had “made the government come to its senses and realise that baseline assessment was never a good idea in the first place”.

Malcolm Trobe, interim leader of the ASCL head teachers’ union, said: “It was too narrow a way of assessing the ability of young children and having different assessment methods in different schools was muddled.”

The education department says it is still committed to the principle of baseline testing and “will continue to look at the best way to assess pupils in the early years”.

As such, baseline tests will remain optional for next year, but will not be used for “accountability purposes”.

Source: Baseline tests dropped as progress measure – BBC News

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.