‘Glass floor’ protecting middle classes from social slide – report

Jul 26, 2015 by


Middle-class children benefit from a “glass floor” protecting them from slipping down the social scale in Britain, a report has said.

The Social Mobility and Child Poverty Commission said better-off families managed to provide educational and social advantages to stop their slide.

It found less able, richer children were 35% more likely to become high earners than brighter, poorer peers.

The government said its reforms were helping disadvantaged pupils catch up.

The report for the commission, which advises the government on social mobility issues, was based on a long-term study of 17,000 British-born children born in a single week in 1970 that measured their ability at the age of five.

It said wealthier families helped their children accumulate skills valued by the labour market and they also used social networks to secure internships and employment.

That meant poorer, but more able children were often blocked from the finite number of top jobs, it added.

‘Extra something’

The report, by Abigail McKnight of the London School of Economics, said parental help may start with providing a good home-learning environment in the early years, and continue with seeking out better schools, offering help with homework and exam preparation.

Parental education level and attendance at a private or grammar school all had a significant impact over and above the influence of academic attainment, it said.

The research suggests there is a clear correlation between the social background of a child’s grandfather and eventual labour market success.

The report also highlighted a “private school wage premium”, where recruitment to high-earning occupations is biased towards those educated in private schools.

Private schools teach skills such as confidence and leadership which can aid progression

It said: “Not only do privately educated children achieve well in examinations and on this basis go on to have highly successful careers, but private school education also bestows a ‘little extra something’.

“Some of the ‘extra’ is made up of soft skills – for example – presentation, conduct in social settings, accent – which have little to do with productivity and a lot to do with what economists refer to as ‘signalling’.”

‘Compensate deprived’

Commission chairman Alan Milburn said nobody should criticise parents for doing their best for their children, but it was not right that the less able do better in life than the more able.

“It has long been recognised that there is a glass ceiling in British society that prevents children with potential progressing to the top. This research reveals there is a glass floor that inhibits social mobility as much as the glass ceiling,” he said.

“It’s a social scandal that all too often demography is still destiny in Britain. The government should make its core mission the levelling of the playing field so that every child in the country has an equal opportunity to go as far as their abilities can take them.”

The report called on the government to seek policies that would compensate children who are deprived of the benefits that children with educated parents receive.

“Careful consideration should be given to the setting of homework, fostering and nurturing aspiration, high quality and age-appropriate education and careers advice, and inspirational high-calibre teachers,” it added.

‘High expectations’

A Department for Education spokesman said: “This government is committed to making sure that every child, regardless of background, has the same opportunities to fulfil their potential.

“Our reforms – including the £2.5bn pupil premium – are seeing results, with disadvantaged pupils catching up with their better off peers at both primary and secondary.

“We have placed high expectations at the heart of our schools, with a rigorous new curriculum, world class exams and a new system rewarding schools that push every child to achieve their best.”

Source: ‘Glass floor’ protecting middle classes from social slide – report – BBC News

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

1 Comment

  1. Avatar

    MERIT knows no skin color or economic class. Those that claim otherwise are the REAL SUPPRESSORS. I know of many “well to do” families with children that are rejecting the very attributes this author claims THOSE kids embrace and FAIL miserably. I know of poor kids that act like savages and make the headlines all the time. All of this is a CHOICE. It is not dependent on skin color, ethnicity or economic status. This is simply a progressive attempt to “level the playing field” based on THEIR bias.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.