The world’s most-surveilled cities

Sep 9, 2019 by

Cities in China are under the heaviest CCTV surveillance in the world, according to a new analysis by Comparitech. However, some residents living in cities across the US, UK, UAE, Australia, and India will also find themselves surrounded by a large number of watchful eyes, as our look at the number of public CCTV cameras in 120 cities worldwide found.

Closed-circuit television (CCTV) cameras serve many purposes, ranging from crime prevention to traffic monitoring to observing industrial operations in environments not suitable for humans. The digital age has boosted the prevalence of CCTV surveillance. Cameras are getting better and cheaper, while live video streams can be remotely accessed, stored on the internet, and passed around. The adoption of face recognition technology makes it possible for both public and private entities to instantly check the identity of anyone who passes by a CCTV camera.

Depending on whom you ask, the increased prevalence and capabilities of CCTV surveillance could make society safer and more efficient, could trample on our rights to privacy and freedom of movement, or both. No matter which side you argue, the fact is that live video surveillance is ramping up worldwide.

Comparitech researchers collated a number of data resources and reports, including government reports, police websites, and news articles, to get some idea of the number of CCTV cameras in use in 120 major cities across the globe. We focused primarily on public CCTV—cameras used by government entities such as law enforcement.

Here are our key findings:

  • Eight out of the top 10 most-surveilled cities are in China
  • London and Atlanta were the only cities outside of China to make the top 10
  • By 2022, China is projected to have one public CCTV camera for every two people
  • We found little correlation between the number of public CCTV cameras and crime or safety

The 20 most-surveilled cities in the world

Based on the number of cameras per 1,000 people, these cities are the top 20 most surveilled in the world:

  1. Chongqing, China – 2,579,890 cameras for 15,354,067 people = 168.03 cameras per 1,000 people
  2. Shenzhen, China – 1,929,600 cameras for 12,128,721 people = 159.09 cameras per 1,000 people
  3. Shanghai, China – 2,985,984 cameras for 26,317,104 people = 113.46 cameras per 1,000 people
  4. Tianjin, China – 1,244,160 cameras for 13,396,402 people = 92.87 cameras per 1,000 people
  5. Ji’nan, China – 540,463 cameras for 7,321,200 people = 73.82 cameras per 1,000 people
  6. London, England (UK) – 627,707 cameras for 9,176,530 people = 68.40 cameras per 1,000 people
  7. Wuhan, China – 500,000 cameras for 8,266,273 people = 60.49 cameras per 1,000 people
  8. Guangzhou, China – 684,000 cameras for 12,967,862 people = 52.75 cameras per 1,000 people
  9. Beijing, China – 800,000 cameras for 20,035,455 people = 39.93 cameras per 1,000 people
  10. Atlanta, Georgia (US) – 7,800 cameras for 501,178 people = 15.56 cameras per 1,000 people
  11. Singapore – 86,000 cameras for 5,638,676 people = 15.25 cameras per 1,000 people
  12. Abu Dhabi, UAE – 20,000 cameras for 1,452,057 people = 13.77 cameras per 1,000 people
  13. Chicago, Illinois (US) – 35,000 cameras for 2,679,044 people = 13.06 cameras per 1,000 people
  14. Urumqi, China – 43,394 cameras for 3,500,000 people = 12.40 cameras per 1,000 people
  15. Sydney, Australia – 60,000 cameras for 4,859,432 people = 12.35 cameras per 1,000 people
  16. Baghdad, Iraq – 120,000 cameras for 9,760,000 people = 12.30 cameras per 1,000 people
  17. Dubai, UAE – 35,000 cameras for 2,883,079 people = 12.14 cameras per 1,000 people
  18. Moscow, Russia – 146,000 cameras for 12,476,171 people = 11.70 cameras per 1,000 people
  19. Berlin, Germany – 39,765 cameras for 3,556,792 people = 11.18 cameras per 1,000 people
  20. New Delhi, India – 179,000 cameras for 18,600,000 people = 9.62 cameras per 1,000 people

The top 50 most-surveilled cities

City Country # of CCTV Cameras # of People # of CCTV Cameras per 1,000 People Crime Index Safety Index
Chongqing China 2,579,890 15,354,067 168.03 33.18 66.82
Shenzhen China 1,929,600 12,128,721 159.09 42.91 57.09
Shanghai China 2,985,984 26,317,104 113.46 40.87 59.13
Tianjin China 1,244,160 13,396,402 92.87 29.15 70.85
Ji’nan China 540,463 7,321,200 73.82 15.93 84.07
London England (UK) 627,707 9,176,530 68.40 52.24 47.76
Wuhan China 500,000 8,266,273 60.49 21.18 78.82
Guangzhou China 684,000 12,967,862 52.75 47.43 52.57
Beijing China 800,000 20,035,455 39.93 42.31 57.69
Atlanta United States 7,800 501,178 15.56 62.86 37.14
Singapore Singapore 86,000 5,638,676 15.25 28.36 71.64
Abu Dhabi UAE 20,000 1,452,057 13.77 10.92 89.08
Chicago United States 35,000 2,679,044 13.06 64.12 35.88
Urumqi China 43,394 3,500,000 12.40 36.76 63.24
Sydney Australia 60,000 4,859,432 12.35 36.02 63.98
Baghdad Iraq 120,000 9,760,000 12.30 63.92 36.08
Dubai UAE 35,000 2,883,079 12.14 16.69 83.31
Moscow Russia 146,000 12,476,171 11.70 40.69 59.31
Berlin Germany 39,765 3,556,792 11.18 40.30 59.70
New Delhi India 179,000 18,600,000 9.62 58.77 41.23
Nanchang China 50,400 5,463,538 9.22 8.09 91.91
Islamabad Pakistan 9,950 1,095,064 9.09 29.30 70.70
Warsaw Poland 13,935 1,775,933 7.85 30.90 69.10
Vienna Austria 14,141 1,915,338 7.38 23.28 76.72
Istanbul Turkey 107,000 14,967,667 7.15 47.73 52.27
Hong Kong Hong Kong 50,000 7,451,000 6.71 18.00 82.00
Changsha China 50,000 7,918,100 6.31 30.37 69.63
Washington, D.C. United States 4,000 713,549 5.61 56.73 43.27
St. Petersburg Russia 30,000 5,426,959 5.53 39.38 60.62
Canberra Australia 2,472 452,497 5.46 19.78 80.22
Bangkok Thailand 53,429 10,350,204 5.16 41.39 58.61
Chennai India 50,000 10,711,243 4.67 40.39 59.61
Madrid Spain 29,000 6,559,041 4.42 30.50 69.50
Seoul South Korea 37,883 9,962,393 3.80 28.90 71.10
Auckland New Zealand 5,577 1,582,028 3.53 45.87 54.13
Budapest Hungary 6,000 1,763,913 3.40 36.75 63.25
Athens Greece 10,612 3,154,152 3.36 48.19 51.81
San Francisco United States 2,753 897,536 3.07 50.52 49.48
Paris France 33,479 10,958,187 3.06 51.40 48.60
Lucknow India 9,300 3,589,795 2.59 45.30 54.70
Salvador Brazil 7,300 2,857,329 2.55 77.90 22.10
San Diego United States 3,600 1,453,775 2.48 36.66 63.34
Toronto Canada 14,955 6,139,404 2.44 36.68 63.32
Sofia Bulgaria 3,000 1,276,937 2.35 42.83 57.17
Nice France 2,145 941,800 2.28 42.44 57.56
Boston United States 1,552 694,784 2.23 33.74 66.26
Prague Czech Republic 2,820 1,298,804 2.17 25.16 74.84
Cardiff Wales (UK) 1,022 474,187 2.16 35.50 64.50
Kiev Ukraine 6,200 2,950,819 2.10 47.23 52.77
Rome Italy 8,300 4,234,019 1.96 52.42 47.58

This spreadsheet contains the figures for all 121 countries and the source for each number.

CCTV, crime, and safety

A primary argument in favor of CCTV surveillance is improved law enforcement and crime prevention. We compared the number of public CCTV cameras with the crime and safety indices reported by Numbeo, which are based on surveys of that site’s visitors.

For both indices, the correlation was weak (r = 0.168, r = -0.168, n = 120). A higher number of cameras just barely correlates with a higher safety index and lower crime index.

Broadly speaking, more cameras doesn’t necessarily result in people feeling safer.

China leads the world in CCTV surveillance

Estimates vary on the number of CCTV cameras in China, but reports range from 200 million up to 626 million in use by 2020.

Based on the country’s current population of 1.4 billion people, that would mean nearly one camera for every two people. Although this projection might seem vast, it may be a fraction of the actual number.

The city of Shenzhen plans to have 16,680,000 cameras installed in the coming years, a 1,145 percent increase over today’s figure of approximately 1,929,600 cameras. If the whole of China increased the number of CCTV cameras by 1,145 percent, that would mean a total of 2.29 billion cameras—just less than two cameras per person.

China is also a fervent adopter of face recognition surveillance. It is often used to restrict individuals’ freedom of movement in combination with the country’s social credit system. If someone’s social credit is too low, for example, they can be barred from using certain types of public transportation. Cameras equipped with face recognition technology are put in place at transportation hubs to enforce these rules.

Methodology

Comparitech researchers collated a number of resources to get an estimate of the number of public CCTV cameras in use. We focused on the world’s most heavily-populated cities but omitted any city where we couldn’t find enough data. Where possible, we have also tried to find the number of private CCTV cameras in use. However, as this isn’t possible for every city, we did not include private CCTV in the overall totals.

For China, we used these sources but also created estimates based on the growth rates indicated in this area. By 2020, China is anticipated to have 626 million CCTV cameras. This 213 percent increase has been applied to our future projections. Equally, if the source for the current CCTV camera numbers was older than 2019, we have applied a 20 percent increase year-on-year. This is the growth rate indicated by the Chinese Ministry of Public Security.

Due to a wide range of sources reporting estimates and a general lack of public information regarding CCTV cameras, actual figures may be higher or lower than what is indicated.

City populations were sourced from World Population Review.

Source: The world’s most-surveilled cities – Comparitech

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.